
16 November 2026
Is it a lease? Identified asset and the right to control
Why the definition of a lease is the most important step in IFRS 16, and how to apply it to common UAE contracts
-- Under [IFRS 16](/services/audit-and-assurance/ifrs-advisory-services), a lessee brings almost every lease onto the balance sheet. That makes the question "is this contract a lease?" far more important than it was under the old standard, because the answer decides whether an asset and a liability are recognised at all. - A contract contains a lease if it conveys the right to control the use of an identified asset for a period of time in exchange for consideration. In practice, that comes down to three questions: is there an identified asset, does the customer get substantially all of its economic benefits, and does the customer direct how and for what purpose it is used? - Many UAE arrangements are not labelled as leases but can meet the definition: dedicated vehicle fleets, specified warehouse units, data centre cages, staff accommodation blocks and some power and cooling contracts. Others that look like leases are in fact services. - Supplier substitution rights, portions of capacity and decisions that were fixed before the contract started are where most of the judgement sits. - The practical answer is a contract review at the point of signing, using a short checklist, rather than a search through the contract archive at the year end."
About this series. This is the first of twelve articles on IFRS 16 Leases, written for UAE finance teams. The series follows a lease through its life: whether a contract contains a lease, how to separate it, how to measure it, how to handle changes, and how leases interact with UAE land rights, lessor accounting, group structures and the new presentation rules under IFRS 18.
Our running case. Throughout the series we follow Dubai Co, a consumer goods distributor and retailer based in mainland Dubai with a 31 December year end. Over the twelve parts, Dubai Co leases a head office, a mall store, a port warehouse and a delivery fleet, takes a musataha over industrial land in Abu Dhabi, sublets space, owns and lets a small retail building, completes a sale and leaseback, moves its stores into a new retail subsidiary, and finally pulls everything together in its lease note. Its counterparties include Sharjah Co, a logistics provider, Abu Dhabi Co, an industrial land developer, and Gulf Bank, its main lender.
Why the definition matters more than the accounting
Before IFRS 16, the distinction that mattered for a lessee was between a finance lease and an operating lease. Operating leases stayed off the balance sheet, and contracts that were not leases at all were treated in much the same way: as an expense when the service or use was received. IFRIC 4 already required entities to identify leases embedded in other contracts, but the answer only changed the numbers if the embedded lease was a finance lease. For the much larger population of embedded operating leases it made little difference, so few entities spent time on the question.
IFRS 16 changed that. A lessee now recognises a right-of-use asset and a lease liability for almost every lease, with exemptions only for short-term and low-value leases. A service contract, on the other hand, remains an expense as the service is received. The definition of a lease has therefore become the gatekeeper for the balance sheet. Get it wrong in one direction and liabilities are understated; get it wrong in the other and assets and liabilities are inflated with arrangements that are really services.
The impact goes beyond the balance sheet. Recognising a lease moves the expense from operating costs into depreciation and interest, which increases reported EBITDA, although cash flows do not change. That affects bank covenants, management bonuses, valuation multiples and the way analysts compare companies. Lenders and analysts have learned to look for arrangements that should have been on the balance sheet and were not.
For lessors, the definition matters too, but the effect is smaller, because lessor accounting under IFRS 16 continues to distinguish between finance and operating leases and the underlying asset usually stays on the lessor’s balance sheet.. Part 9 of this series covers the lessor side.
The three questions
Under IFRS 16, a contract is, or contains, a lease if it conveys the right to control the use of an identified asset for a period of time in exchange for consideration (paragraph 9). The assessment is made at the inception of the contract, which is the earlier of the date of the agreement and the date the parties commit to its main terms, and is only revisited if the terms and conditions change (paragraph 11). The standard turns the definition into a sequence of questions, and it helps to work through them in order.
| Question | If yes | If no |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Is there an identified asset, either specified in the contract or implicitly specified when it is made available, and without a substantive supplier right to substitute it? | Go to question 2 | Not a lease |
| 2. Does the customer have the right to obtain substantially all the economic benefits from use of the asset throughout the period of use? | Go to question 3 | Not a lease |
| 3. Who has the right to direct how and for what purpose the asset is used throughout the period of use? | Customer: lease | Supplier: not a lease |
| 3a. If those decisions are predetermined, can the customer operate the asset (or direct others to operate it as the customer determines) without the supplier being able to change those instructions, or did the customer design it in a way that predetermines how it is used? | Lease | Not a lease |
The order matters because it stops the analysis early in the easy cases. A contract for "up to 500 pallet positions anywhere in our network" fails at the first question and there is no need to think about control. A contract for a specified floor in a specified building passes the first two questions quickly, and the real analysis is about who decides how the floor is used.
The identified asset
An asset is usually identified by being explicitly specified in the contract: a named vessel, a unit number in a building, a vehicle by its chassis number. It can also be implicitly specified at the time it is made available for use. A contract for “a crane with a 200-tonne capacity” does not name a crane, but once the supplier delivers a particular crane to site for the customer’s use, that crane is implicitly identified, because an asset can be identified at the time it is made available (paragraph B13). The next question is whether the supplier has a substantive right to swap it for another.
Substitution rights
Even if an asset is specified, the customer does not have the right to use an identified asset if the supplier has a substantive right to substitute it throughout the period of use. The word "substantive" is doing a lot of work. A substitution right is substantive only if both of the following are true.
| Test or Rule | What it means in practice | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Practical ability | The supplier can substitute alternative assets throughout the period of use, and the customer cannot prevent it | A storage provider can move goods between identical bays without the customer's consent |
| Economic benefit | The supplier would benefit economically from substituting, so that the benefits exceed the costs | The provider moves goods frequently to optimise space across many customers |
| Not substantive | Substitution is only allowed on a future date or event, or only when the asset is not working properly, or would be too costly to be realistic | A vehicle can be replaced only for repairs or maintenance |
| Presumption | If the customer cannot readily determine whether the right is substantive, it presumes that it is not | A clause allows substitution, but the customer has no information about the supplier's fleet or costs |
Contracts in the UAE often contain substitution clauses that are drafted to protect the supplier but would never be used in practice. A logistics provider that has branded trucks in the customer's livery, fitted to the customer's specification, is unlikely to benefit from swapping them. A right to replace a truck when it breaks down does not prevent the truck from being identified. The test looks at economic substance, not at the existence of a clause.
Portions of an asset
A portion of an asset can be an identified asset if it is physically distinct, such as one floor of a building, a specified unit in a mall or a defined cage in a data centre. A capacity portion that is not physically distinct, such as a share of the capacity of a pipeline, a district cooling plant or a fibre optic cable, is not an identified asset unless it represents substantially all the capacity of the asset, so that the customer in effect gets the benefit of the whole asset.
This distinction is particularly relevant in the UAE. District cooling contracts for a building typically give a right to a contracted capacity from a plant that serves many buildings, so they are usually not leases of the plant. A dedicated cooling plant built for a single development, with the customer taking all its output, is a different matter and needs assessing. The plant is not the only asset to look at. Many contracts also place an energy transfer station, the heat exchange equipment, inside the customer’s building. That equipment is physically distinct and dedicated to one customer, so it should be assessed separately. Whether it is a lease depends on who has the right to direct its use and on whether the provider has a substantive right to replace or relocate it.
Substantially all the economic benefits
The customer must have the right to obtain substantially all the economic benefits from using the asset throughout the period of use. Economic benefits include the primary output and by-products, and other benefits from using the asset that could be realised in a transaction with a third party. They are assessed within the scope of the customer's right of use. A contract that limits a vehicle to use within the UAE does not prevent the customer from obtaining substantially all the benefits of using it within that area.
Payments that depend on the customer's revenue do not change the analysis. A retailer that pays a mall owner a percentage of its sales still obtains substantially all the benefits from using its unit; the percentage rent is simply part of the consideration. Because it is a variable payment linked to sales, it is not included in the lease liability (paragraph 38(b)), which Part 3 covers. The question typically fails where someone else, such as the supplier or another customer, also uses the asset in a meaningful way, for example a shared office floor or a vessel that carries cargo for several parties on the same voyage. If the customer controls the asset for only part of the contract term, the contract contains a lease for that part only.
The right to direct the use
The third question is usually the deciding one. A customer has the right to direct the use of an asset if it can direct how and for what purpose the asset is used throughout the period of use. The relevant decisions are those that most affect the economic benefits derived from use, such as what the asset produces, when, where and how much.
Decisions about operating and maintaining the asset are generally not relevant on their own. A supplier that provides a driver for a truck, or maintains a warehouse's racking system, is not directing the use if the customer decides where the truck goes and what it carries. Equally, protective rights that the supplier includes in the contract, such as limits on the maximum load or a ban on entering certain areas, protect the supplier's asset without taking away the customer's right to direct its use.
Sometimes the relevant decisions are predetermined by the contract or the design of the asset. A solar plant built to the customer's specification, with all output going to the customer, leaves few decisions to make during its use. In that case, the customer has the right to direct the use if it has the right to operate the asset, or to direct others to operate it as it determines, without the supplier being able to change those instructions (paragraph B24(b)(i)), or if it designed the asset in a way that predetermines how and for what purpose it will be used (paragraph B24(b)(ii)). This is how some power purchase agreements and build-to-suit facilities end up containing leases.
UAE arrangements put to the test
Applying the three questions to contracts that UAE businesses sign every day shows how often the answer differs from the label on the contract.
| Arrangement | Typical facts | Likely conclusion |
|---|---|---|
| Office or retail unit | Specified unit, tenant fits out and decides how to use it within the permitted use in the tenancy contract | Lease |
| Shared warehouse space | A number of pallet positions in a multi-client facility; provider moves goods between bays | Service: no identified asset |
| Dedicated warehouse unit | Specified, enclosed unit used only by the customer, with its own access; the customer decides what is stored and how the unit is used | Lease |
| Dedicated truck fleet with drivers | Specified trucks in customer livery; customer decides routes and loads; supplier provides drivers | Lease of the trucks, with a service component for drivers and maintenance |
| Pool vehicle arrangements | Provider supplies any vehicle of a category on request from a shared fleet | Service |
| Staff accommodation | Specified rooms or a whole building allocated exclusively to the company's staff | Lease, subject to the short-term lease exemption in Part 6 where it applies. Rooms or buildings will rarely qualify as low-value assets. |
| Data centre cage | Specified, physically separated cage; customer installs and runs its own servers | Lease of the cage space, with hosting services as non-lease components |
| Cloud computing | Access to a provider's computing capacity, with no specified hardware | Service |
| Telecom tower space | Right to place antennas on a specified tower location | Often a lease of the space; depends on substitution rights |
| District cooling | Contracted capacity from a plant serving many buildings | Service for the plant capacity. Assess any equipment installed in the customer’s building separately |
| Power purchase agreement | All output of a specified solar plant designed to the customer's requirements | Assess carefully: may contain a lease |
Two observations stand out. First, many contracts contain both a lease and services, which is why Part 2 of this series deals with separating components. Second, the same type of arrangement can go either way depending on the facts. Data centres and telecom towers are examples: a specified cage is a lease, while the same capacity delivered from any rack the provider chooses is not.
Running case: Dubai Co's logistics contract
Dubai Co signs a five-year contract with Sharjah Co, a logistics provider, starting on 1 January 2026. The contract covers two services for an annual fee of AED 3.6 million.
- Delivery fleet. Ten trucks, identified by chassis number, painted in Dubai Co's colours and fitted with temperature-controlled units to Dubai Co's specification. Sharjah Co supplies drivers and carries out maintenance. Dubai Co decides daily routes, delivery schedules and which goods each truck carries. Sharjah Co may replace a truck only while it is being repaired and must then return it.
- Storage. Up to 2,000 pallet positions in Sharjah Co's multi-client warehouse. Sharjah Co decides where in the warehouse Dubai Co's goods are stored and moves them between bays regularly to make best use of space for all its customers.
The analysis of each element is set out below.
| Question | Delivery fleet | Storage |
|---|---|---|
| Identified asset? | Yes. Trucks are specified by chassis number. The right to replace them only during repairs is not a substantive substitution right. | No. Pallet positions are not specified and the provider has, and uses, a practical ability to move goods. It benefits from doing so. |
| Substantially all economic benefits? | Yes. The trucks are used only for Dubai Co's deliveries for five years. | Not needed: fails the first question. |
| Right to direct the use? | Yes. Dubai Co decides where and when the trucks go and what they carry. The provider's drivers and maintenance are operating decisions, not decisions about how and for what purpose the trucks are used. | Not needed. |
| Conclusion | The contract contains a lease of ten trucks. | Storage is a service, expensed as received. |
Dubai Co therefore recognises a right-of-use asset and a lease liability for the trucks at the commencement date, expected to be 1 January 2026 when the trucks are made available. The AED 3.6 million annual fee covers the trucks, the drivers, maintenance and storage, so Dubai Co needs to allocate it between the lease component and the non-lease components. For the drivers and maintenance, it can instead elect the practical expedient for the class of vehicles and account for them together with the trucks as a single lease component (paragraph 15). The unrelated storage service is a separate non-lease component and receives its own share of the fee. That is the subject of Part 2.
The conclusion would change if the facts were different. If the provider had a large pool of identical trucks and assigned whichever trucks were available each day, the substitution right would likely be substantive and there would be no lease. If the warehouse contract gave Dubai Co a specified, enclosed section with its own access and no right for the provider to move goods, the storage would likely contain a lease too.
Building a contract review into the process
The most common reason leases are missed is not a technical misjudgement. It is that nobody in finance saw the contract. Procurement, operations and IT sign agreements for vehicles, equipment, space and capacity every week, and many of them never pass through the team that maintains the lease register. A short checklist, completed when a contract is signed and attached to the purchase order, solves most of the problem.
| Checklist question | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Does the contract involve the use of a physical asset, such as space, vehicles, equipment, plant or infrastructure? | If not, it is very unlikely to contain a lease |
| Is the asset, or a physically distinct part of it, specified in the contract or by how it is delivered? | Identifies the asset |
| Can the supplier swap the asset for another at any time, and would it actually benefit from doing so? | Tests substitution rights |
| Does anyone other than us use the asset during the contract? | Tests substantially all the economic benefits |
| Do we decide what the asset is used for, when, where and how much? | Tests the right to direct the use |
| If those decisions were fixed at the start, did we design the asset or can we operate it (or direct who does) without the supplier being able to change our instructions? | Covers predetermined use |
| What is the term, including options, and what are the payments? | Needed for measurement if it is a lease |
The completed checklist goes to the lease accounting owner, who decides whether the contract contains a lease and updates the register. It also creates the audit trail that auditors will ask for when they test the completeness of the lease population.
Common pitfalls we see in practice
- Relying on the contract title. Agreements called "service agreement", "hire agreement" or "capacity agreement" are assumed not to be leases, without applying the three questions.
- Accepting every substitution clause at face value. Substitution rights that would never be exercised, or that apply only for repairs, are treated as substantive.
- Only looking at property. The lease register covers offices and shops but misses vehicles, equipment, data centre space and dedicated logistics assets.
- Missing embedded leases. Leases hidden inside larger contracts, such as outsourcing, logistics, power supply and facilities management agreements, are never identified.
- Treating operating decisions as control. A supplier that provides drivers or operators is assumed to control the asset, even though the customer decides how and for what purpose it is used.
- No documentation. The conclusion may be right, but there is no record of the analysis, so it has to be reconstructed for the auditors.
Conclusion
Under IFRS 16, the definition of a lease decides what goes onto the balance sheet. Everything that follows in this series, from measurement to disclosure, depends on getting that first step right. The three questions are simple to state but require judgement, particularly on substitution rights, portions of capacity and arrangements where the use was fixed at the start.
The practical message is to assess contracts when they are signed, not when the auditors ask. A short checklist attached to every contract that involves the use of a physical asset, reviewed by someone who understands IFRS 16, catches most embedded leases and creates the documentation needed to support the conclusion. It is a far cheaper control than discovering a missing lease, and restating the numbers, after the financial statements have been issued.
How CLA Emirates can help
Our team helps UAE entities get their lease population right. We can help you:
- Review your contract portfolio, including service and supply agreements, to identify embedded leases.
- Design a contract review checklist and process that fits your procurement workflow.
- Document lease assessments for complex arrangements such as logistics, data centre and power contracts.
- Support your discussions with auditors on judgemental conclusions.
Coming next in the series. Part 2 looks at contracts that combine a lease with services, such as Dubai Co's logistics deal with Sharjah Co and the typical UAE mall lease with service charges and chiller fees, and explains how to separate and allocate the payments.
Author

Email Subscriptions
Right there with you, delivering insights and event invitations straight to your inbox.